MITCHELL INSURANCE GROUP CUSTOMER SERVICE CENTER NO MATTER WHAT YOU NEED, WE'RE HERE TO HELP CUSTOMER SELF SERVICE Make a Change, Get ID Cards and Proof of Insurance Instantly. REQUEST INSURANCE CARDS Request an Insurance card for your car, boat, or motorcycle policy, fast but not instant. BILLING & PAYMENTS Find billing and payment info for our insurance carriers. SUBMIT A CLAIM Contact info for your insurance companies claims center. CERTIFICATE REQUEST Request a certificate of insurance for your policy.